The Rusty Pig in Geneva, NY brings together the best of a classic American restaurant experience with a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel easy and enjoyable. Known for its burgers, BBQ, and craft beer, this laid-back neighborhood favorite offers the kind of hearty, satisfying food people come back for again and again.
From lunch and dinner to solo dining, quick bites, and late-night cravings, The Rusty Pig is built around comfort, convenience, and flavor.
Guests can enjoy a full dine-in experience, grab takeout, order delivery, or settle in outdoors, making it a flexible choice whether you are planning a casual meal, meeting friends, or looking for a dependable spot for great food and drinks.
The experience is shaped by both quality and atmosphere. With fast service, a standout beer selection, creative cocktails, and local specialties on the menu, The Rusty Pig delivers more than just a meal—it creates a place where guests can unwind and enjoy themselves.
The setting adds to the appeal, with rustic details, a cozy yet lively vibe, and thoughtful touches like bar seating, table service, and a welcoming dining room that feels comfortable without losing its energy.
Whether you are stopping in for comfort food, small plates, dessert, coffee, or a drink at the bar, the restaurant offers the kind of variety and consistency that makes it a dependable choice for many occasions. Catering is also available, adding extra value for gatherings and events that call for crowd-pleasing American favorites.
Accessibility and convenience are clearly part of the experience as well. The Rusty Pig provides wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating, and restrooms, helping ensure that more guests can enjoy the restaurant with ease and confidence. Reservations are accepted, and payment is simple with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
With a strong 4.60-star rating from 1,268 reviews, the restaurant has earned the trust of locals and visitors alike for its service, atmosphere, and food.
Located at 60 Seneca St in Geneva, The Rusty Pig stands out as an inviting destination for anyone looking for a high-quality American restaurant where good food, great drinks, and a comfortable setting come together naturally.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at The Rusty Pig
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
American lager san antonio, tx -4.8% abv-10 ibu 16 oz
#Billsmafia rochester, ny-4% 16oz abv-5 ibu teku
Green tea sour beacon, ny-6% . Abv teku
Cider - traditional canandaigua, ny. • . 16oz
Scotch ale scottish ale geneva, ny -6.1% abv 13oz shifter
Stout - other - buffalo, ny - 5.2% abv - 31 ibu 13oz shifter
Double milk stout - lakewood, ny - 10% abv - 25 ibu 13oz shifter
American ipa - freeport, me - 7% abv teku
Double ipa - bloomfield, ny - 8.6% abv teku
Double new england ipa east hampton, ct - 9% abv 13oz shifter
Cranberry cider - canandaigua, ny - 7% abv 16oz
Craft soda, geneva ny 16oz
American wild ale - austin, tx - 8% abv 12.7oz bottle
(2018) lambic - kriek lot, vlaanderen. 6% abv. 12.7oz bottle
Lambic - framboise lot, vlaanderen - 6% abv 12.7oz bottle
(2019) lambic - gueuze - rebecq, wallonie - 7% abv. .375ml bottle
(2017) sour-swiss ale de garde- saignelégier, jura 11% abv. 25.4oz bottle
(2019) stout - imperial krebs, ok -15% abv 12oz bottle
(2019) imperial / double truckee, ca .11.9% abv 500ml bottle
(2020 dark matter coffee) imperial coffee stout st louis, mo 11.5% abv 16oz can
(2020) stout - imperial mt pleasant, sc-10.5% abv 650ml bottle
Level mild.featuring sweet brown sugar caramelized onions and pabst blue ribbon beer. Sweet but not too sweet, this one has great flavor but no heat at all!
Level mild.a tangy, mustard based gold bbq sauce that tastes like a summer cookout thanks to a heavy dose of prairie artisan bomb beer, honey, and our previously secret ingredient-sauerkraut!! Don't look back
Level medium.formerly "wimp sauce" - a toned-down bbq " featuring charred poblano peppers, apples. And honey with just a touch of heat!
Level medium.previously known as "wing sauce", our buffalo style #17 is not your average wing sauce! Sweet, spicy, and just so right, we had to name it after josh allen!
Level medium.a 50/50 blend of our house bbq and recipe #17. It's a banger for sure, and not just on drumsticks!
Level hot.sweet and smoky, a tangy bite, and the lingering slow burn of chipotle peppers. Well balanced and damn delicious!
Level hot.not for the faint of heart! This mouth burner features smoked habanero peppers for a super-hot sauce that tastes like fresh habanero peppers and burnin' love!!
Ipa imperial middletown, ny -8.5% abv
Ipa - imperial - middletown, ny 8.5% abv
Stout - imperial waitsfield, vt 10.1% abv
Carvel ice cream cake stout elmsford, ny 6% abv 16oz can
Apple fritter cider lafayette, ny 6.9% abv.
Barrel aged wild ale with raspberries chicago, il. 8.7% abv 12oz
Barrel aged farmhouse ale with peaches chicago, il 7.5% abv 12oz
Barrel aged wild ale with cherries chicago, il 6.7% abv 12oz
Passion fruit milkshake sour corfu,6.5% abv
Plum cherry sour toronto, on 5.6% abv
Sour - fruited. Alexandria, va -5% abv
Wheat beer - witbier boston, ma 5.1% abv 12oz
Lager - american light milwaukee, wi - 4.2% abv 16oz
Lager - american light golden, co 4.2% abv 16oz
Hear from our valued guests
Had a great dinner here with a group of friends. The took a reservation for 8 and we arrived early and got seated immediately. Great selection of beers and food. Had a combo plate with some excellent bbq. Kind of limited seating so reservations are highly recommended.
First off the restaurant is beautiful inside. Very smooth atmosphere, busy but quiet enough to enjoy a conversation. My favorite is their menu. Creative and plentiful. Perfectly done. And of course the food is absolutely delicious. Drink menu complements the food exceptionally! Absolutely love to come here!
Great experience! We loved sitting outside, service was so attentive as we our hostess, and the food was delicious! We'll definitely be back and spoke highly about our experience to friends and family too!
Great Find. We ran into the place right after they opened on a rainy Saturday. Not busy when we arrived but filled up right after. Our server (Gail) was outstanding, a friendly professional. We ordered the meatloaf and the brisket with some extra sides. All the food was crazy good. BBQ can be tricky... this was fantastic. There were many other choices on the menu that we will get back to try as well. Service was awesome, no real wait at all. The vibe was great even though the weather outside sucked. Looking forward to getting back there and maybe sitting outdoors next time. Geneva downtown looks like a great place to walk around after.
--- 08/01/2025 --- Back again and sat at the bar with the Mrs. She got the Mac and cheese and I got the St Louis ribs. Great food and good service... always a good combo! --- ORIGINAL REVIEW --- Our 1st visit (06/03/2025) but definitely not our last. The beer cheese nachos were 💣 and the brisket cheese steak was freaking delicious 😋 We will have to return to try other menu items as they clearly know how to cook! I didn't care for their iced tea... tasted bitter to me... but I'm a bit of an iced tea snob. 🙃
Awesome experience. Was here with a large group and everything was handled fantastically. I got the brisket with a side of chili. The brisket was tender and delicious! The chili... Oh my! The flavor was phenomenal and the heat was perfect. I used the little cornbread loaf to do in the chili and what an awesome flavor combo!!
The ribs are amazing. Just the right amount of sweet and savory. Pulled pork tacos were good as well (very filling). Kids had chicken and waffles and they were very pleased. All in all a solid place to eat with the family.
My wife and I went here with friends who were visiting. I’ve never been and I’ve only heard good things about The Rusty Pig. The waitress was very kind and let us take our time with the menu. The acoustics of the restaurant made it a little difficult to hear. We had to talk louder than normal and lean forward. We were also seated next to other smaller occupied tables, where there were people seated already. If we had been spaced out a little bit more, that might have helped with the hearing. The first thing we decided to split was the Loaded Buffalo Pierogis. They were deliciously flavored and not too hot. All 4 of us ordered something different. I ordered The Pink Lady Chicken Sandwich with a side of Mac and cheese (because you HAVE to try that). They were both very yummy and filling. My spouse got Heavy Kevi’s Famous Brisket with cornbread, apple slaw and Mac and cheese. The food was filling and it could have been two meals. We finished the day with Caramel S’mores Nachos, which was very gooey and exactly as you’d expect for a plate of sweet fried dough. Overall, it’s a worthwhile experience to stop in and try one of Geneva’s best known restaurants.
Pretty solid bbq in ny. The brisket was ok. The ribs and the pulled pork were definitely the better options of the platter for 2. The sides to get are the fries and beans. The slaw was too sweet personally
The food here was near perfect the portions were large and the service was excellent they have a wide variety of meat choices and we all got something different and each of them were very good. Highly recommended.
Common questions about The Rusty Pig
The Rusty Pig is located at 60 Seneca St, Geneva, NY 14456, United States, Geneva, NY, United States.
You can reach The Rusty Pig by calling +1 315-325-4548.
The Rusty Pig has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 based on 1268 customer reviews.
The Rusty Pig features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible seating, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
The Rusty Pig features the following service options: Outdoor seating, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in, Delivery.
The Rusty Pig features the following highlights: Fast service, Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Serves local specialty.
The Rusty Pig features the following popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining.
The Rusty Pig features the following offerings: Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Comfort food, Late-night food, Quick bite, Small plates, Spirits, Vegan options, Wine.
The Rusty Pig features the following dining options: Lunch, Dinner, Catering, Counter service, Dessert, Seating, Table service.
The Rusty Pig features the following amenities: Bar on site, Restroom.
The Rusty Pig features the following atmosphere: Casual, Cozy, Lively, Trendy.
The Rusty Pig features the following crowd: Groups, Tourists.
The Rusty Pig features the following planning: Accepts reservations.
The Rusty Pig features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
The Rusty Pig features the following children: Good for kids, High chairs.
The Rusty Pig features the following parking: Free parking lot, Free street parking, Plenty of parking.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
